Tuesday, Jun 2, 2020

Supreme Court Debates What Makes a Minister and Job Discrimination

Another case involving Christian teachers challenges the “ministerial exception” that shields religious institutions from certain anti-discrimination lawsuits.

Must Read

The Salty Christian: Are We Effective Athletes on Team Jesus?

As believers, we are called to be salt and season the world. How can we be more effective witnesses for God on Team Jesus?

The Good & Perfect Gift of Diversity and Why God Hates Racism

If diversity is part of God's plan for humanity, where does that leave racism? God hates racism - and for good reasons. Here's why!

In All the Places Without Cameras, Let’s Be Our Brother’s Keeper

As followers of Christ, let’s commit to being our brother’s keeper, in every situation, regardless of cost—with or without cameras.

The Supreme Court seemed divided over how broadly religious institutions including schools, hospitals, and social service centers should be shielded from job discrimination lawsuits by employees.

The court heard arguments by telephone, with the audio available live, for a second week because of the coronavirus pandemic. The court has two days left of scheduled telephone arguments. Tuesday’s arguments are high-profile fights over President Donald Trump’s financial records.

Recently, the high court heard a case stemming from a unanimous 2012 Supreme Court decision in which the justices said the Constitution prevents ministers from suing their churches for employment discrimination. But the court didn’t rigidly define who counts as a minister.

Lawyer Eric Rassbach, representing two Catholic schools sued by former fifth-grade teachers who taught religion among other subjects, told the justices that the women count as ministers exempt from suing.

“If separation of church and state means anything at all, it must mean that government cannot interfere with the church’s decisions about who is authorized to teach its religion,” Rassbach told the justices.

But the court struggled Monday with who should count as a minister, with the court’s four more liberal members expressing concern about broadening the current exception.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor, a member of the court’s liberal wing, told Rassbach that he was seeking an exception that was “broader than is necessary to protect the church.”

Justice Elena Kagan, meanwhile, asked whether a series of people working for religious institutions would count as a minister, including a math teacher who begins class with a prayer, …

Continue reading

News brought to you by Christianity Today

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Featured

00:01:57

Mental Health: How Do I Hear God’s Voice with Other Voices in My Head?

When dealing with mental health challenges, how can we hear God's voice when we hear other voices? Try these tips from Dr. Thema Bryant-Davis.

Online Church During a Crisis: 7 Tips for Better Online Worship Services

The necessity and convenience of online church are undeniable, especially in a crisis. Try these 7 tips to improve your church's online worship experience.

The Rainbow Belongs to God: Teen Takes a Stand for God in Nike Kyrie 5 Shoes

California teen takes a bold stand for God and the rainbow in his Nike Kyrie 5 rainbow shoes. Take a walk in the shoes of this young teammate.

Living Fit and Free: One Woman’s Story of Quitting Diets and Finding Health

Are you struggling to get off diet plans and make peace with your body image? Be inspired by Marsha Apsley and her journey to living fit and free.

Team Jesus Locker Room Chat w/ Greg Kirkland, Jr.

Teammate Greg Kirkland, Jr., founder of The SEEiT Choir, shares his testimony on life, family, and the heart behind his "SEEiT" brand.
- Advertisement -

More Articles Like This

News brought to you by Christianity Today

X